Yetty`s Pizza & Pasta in Herkimer

My daughter and I were heading home and quickly stopped her for a few slices. They were really friendly. The pizza was alright, but pizza by the slice at 9pm on a Sunday isn't usually the greatest. The price was also pretty good for three slices. I would be interested in sitting down for a meal here and seeing what else they have available?

Food is excellent. Service is great. Recommend to anyone.

Called to place an order as we have done plenty of times before after making the order and given my phone number was told we could not place the order because we canceled an order back in December was told that the order was all ready made when we canceled problem is we canceled while still on the phone with the person who was taking our order we were then told until we pay for the December order we could no longer order from them.i called back after they told my girl this and explained to the manager that I my self have been in the food industryfor the better half of 20 years and that there was no why they could have had the order prepared heile I was still on the phone with the person taking my order the manager told me thanks for me feedback and hung up on me. Way to do business I'll never be back and will post this everywhere

Steak and greens on a panini was excellent . Would definitely go again. Very large menu selection.

Food and service were excellent as usual. Quite busy on friday night. Had a slightly longer than usual wait, but oh so worth it. 😊👍👍😏.

We came all the way from Utica because we saw on tv we took our daughter to eat so disappointed literally there 45 min until appetizers and came came out. Suckssssss

The food ended up being put into "to go" boxes. Once we had waited forever they realized what happened. They replanted the food and brought it out. We were happy to have our food, but it was cold. An offhanded comment was made from thr waitress about if "she could make it herself she would have". When she brought us the bill one meal was removed. Fair enough. Everyone had bad nights. Will go again.

Great food! Been a few years, stopped in for lunch...everything was outstanding.

Good food good portions and good service

One of my all time favorite places to eat. Love the atmosphere, and friendly staff.

yeti's has been a Herkimer staple for many years their food is outstanding their service is awesome and their prices are fantastic

It was great like always.

If you're ever in Herkimer NY you've got to stop by Yetty's their Italian food is delicious and the service was good I highly recommend this place especially if you're in your mood for a good calzone

Their stuffed shells are out of this world...good smells of HOME cooking...yummmmmmmm!!!

Great pizza thick with lots of toppings. A little different with the sauce on top.

They never answer the phone for order pick up

Great food, romantic atmosphere. One of our favs!!

Great food. Kitchen is a bit slow, but food is really good. Tried a few things and never disappointed. Big portions too. Nice people. Great waitresses Try the upside down pizza - EXCELLENT

Ordered. Pd over phone. Went to pick up long line and after 30 minutes plus of waiting they told me they didn't have steak so couldn't complete order.ugh. asked for owner Felicia would not talk to me finally did and was so rude to me and another customer whose $50 order was given to somebody else and they wouldn't even bring it to her house for free. Felicia told the staff member don't worry about it they're only customers. I get things happen but when your a business owner u should handle things better. Never w go BK. This is the second time she was rude to us

I used to work in Herkimer and would occasionally order some pizza and wings from here for the crew. Stopped out a few weeks ago and got some creamy western wings and they were just as good as I remembered them.

Order a large sausage and pepper pizza and 2 pounds of creamy western wings. Dunk all your crusts in the leftover sauce. Then get the fried dough for dessert and you just had the best meal of your life. I will fight anyone on this :)

Super menu. Great prices. Best quality service.

This restaurant is a must stop every time I visit central NY! The western wings and any pasta dish are worth every calorie! Dana was fantastic & we really enjoyed our time.

Excellent food. Our waitress was excellent too. Sorry don't remember name...will surely visit again when in the area..Highly recommended.

Good food good service

I went to herkimer to visit a friend...she suggested this place for dinner,after telling me about their unique style of making pizza,I was intrigued, we got a small sausage pie,it was delicious I really liked it.The homemade sausage was delicious....We also had dinners,that were delicious,served with a salad and garlic bread...I was really impressed with Yetty's..and will go back again sometime..

When we arrived, Terry's was very busy and only one waitress was visible in the dining room. We opted to sit outside. Both tables were previously occupied.. and still contained the dishes left over from the previous diners. She apologized and immediately cleaned a table for us. She came back with the menus, made us aware of the specials and took our drink order. Despite the dining room being full, our meals arrived quickly and were delicious. Good food and great service. I would have taken photos but my cellphone was in need of a charge.

Always the best. I've been eating pizza here for more years than I care to remember, and it never disappoints.

Good Italian Food in a warm cozy environment.

Friend placed order over the phone. was some confusion on the order. got a yetty's pizza instead of a meatza. Called back to tell them. didn't expect much. but they rushed out the right pizza right away to us. Was pretty good pizza and love the fries . Great place.

Food is good. However placed an order. When we went to pick it up didn't have it and said we never placed the order. Called again to place order. When we picked it up never offered a discount on the order for making a mistake. Will think twice about ordering from them again

The shrimp Alfredo was THE BEST I've had in a long time

The server here was quite friendly and attentive and had a wonderful smile. We arrived near the end of the evening but were well taken care of. The food was quite delicious, do yourself a favor and stop for dinner if you are in town.

Excellent service, good food, best Chef Salad ❣️❣️❣️😋😋😋

Best pizza ever. Paul's original sausage mushroom peppers,extra sauce.

Awesome food. Buy from here.

Good menu choices. Great service. Great food. Friendly dining atmosphere.

Thanks for getting gluten free pizza and pasta.

Still the best in the Valley. First time I've been in there in over 10 yrs. So worth the trip from Syracuse 👍

Great food and atmosphere.

We are officially done with Yetty’s. What once was one of our favorite restaurants has continued to decline over the years. We haven’t had one good or correct order the last half dozens times we have ordered. If you are looking for mediocre food that won’t be made how you order it this is your place! I’m not one to leave a bad review after one bad meal because everyone has an off day, but a half dozen over a period of time is unacceptable. Tonights meal was came with two salads completely wrong, two sandwiches missing the paid for toppings and a cold lasagna.

it's Great 😊 and Great service. Especially today

Love the upside-down pizza and calzone-subs! Friendly service! Thanks!

One if my favorites, the food is great and I love to sit out on the deck when the weather is nice enough to do so

The suggestion was made to try the wings and share a Ceasar Salad. The meal was fantastic! We ate out on the small shaded patio on a beautiful late summer day. The casual meal with family friends was very memorable.It is worth getting off the Throughway for!

Amazing food and friendly staff. Only end up getting Yetty's maybe twice a year but it's always top notch. Even highly recommended people I met in Ohio to go online and have some shipped to them since their idea of good pizza is Little Cesar's quality.

Good food good service support local businesses

Food has been good both times we stopped here. Recommend the creamy Western wings. Had meals one time, pizza the other. Unusual and good. Servers are nice, but there was only one person on at 9pm on a Saturday night, so the wait was pretty long.

Once again I went against my better judgement and ordered yettys. Get home .well no wings. No blue cheeseburger celery. Called was on hold for several minutes and noone could figure out why i didnt get the food. Apparently she didnt hear me when I said the small pizza and wing deal. Hmmm. Just a joke going there 3 out of the last four times they messed up

We have been going to Yetty's for a year now. We love this place. How ever the food quality is not consistant. The Lasgna is made on Tuesday for Wednesdays specials have gone later in the week on friday or Saturday. Lasgna was watery and had an internal temp of 98. Which made the inside was like warm.internal temp was suppose to be 140 degrees. We apologized several times how sorry we were they had a new cook this time with no experience, no reason to jeopardize customer safety. We will not be going back. Can not afford to get sick. This was the second time this has happened.